This blog explores popular film and media and their relationship to the environment.
Wednesday, July 20, 2016
Outlander and the Battle Between Tourism and Green Energy
The Starz series Outlander (2014- ) reconstructs its 18th century settings with a keen eye towards authenticity. Despite its fantastical time travel plot, the series strives for historical accuracy in its portrayal of characters, both urban and rural settings, and historical events, such as the Jacobite uprisings of the 1740s. This authenticity extends to the main character Claire's (Caitrona Balfe) nursing profession and its natural medicinal herb roots. Claire's gathering of natural medicines becomes a plot point in many of the series' episodes, but it also emphasizes her character's connection to the natural world.
Nature and culture are interdependent in the series. Humanity has not yet fully dominated the natural world and must battle its curses (such as small pox) and relish its benefits (such as Claire's herbal medicines). It comes as a surprise, then, that the author of the novels on which the series are closely based opposes the green energy of a wind farm because it would obscure the natural beauty of the Rannoch Moores of Scotland.
A May 2015 article in the Independent explores what they call a "battle raging over the future of the rugged landscape, pitting the American novelist behind the series against a Dutch company which wants to build an “industrial-scale” windfarm in the area." Although some do support the wind farm because it contributes to Scotland's goal to move its energy away from fossil fuels and focus exclusively on renewable sources, most object to the farm because it may hurt the country's tourism industry.
Outlander is one reason for these objections. According to the article, "the novel's series author Diana Gabaldon said it would be 'insane' for Scotland to position the proposed 24 400ft-high wind turbines in one of its most beautiful regions and has called on the country’s official tourism body to intervene." The novels and television series Outlander brings tourists to Scotland, and these potential consumers seem to trump renewable energy, at least for now.
Tuesday, July 12, 2016
Silent Running (1971) and Eco-Memory
Silent Running (1971) responds
to two cultures of the 1970s, a changing Hollywood and a shifting Washington
atmosphere. The film’s environmental message slaps viewers in the face: If we
don’t take care of our forests, they will die. As David Lichtneker puts it,
“the eco message is a bit heavy handed (aided by the Joan Baez soundtrack).”
Frederic Brussat, however, suggests that the film “surpasses other ecology
films in its ability to stir our awareness and imaginatively create concern for
the consequences of ecological neglect.” Brussat, one of the editors of the Spirituality and Health movie review
section, even calls Freeman’s character a hero whose “ecological conscience is
a challenge to us all.”
The dated Baez music and
didactic message, however, are not the only qualities that connect the film to
its 1970s context. Created for under a million dollars, Douglas Trumbull’s Silent Running was one of
the five movies with new directors authorized by Ned Tanen, producer in charge
of Universal’s and Lew Wasserman’s youth division. It was Trumbull’s directorial debut, although
his special effects skills were well-respected (see 2001: A Space Odyssey [1968]).
Movie-making moved from the studio’s to the director’s hands under Tanen’s
plan, with the studio taking a hands-off approach to production, a big change
in Hollywood, and one reason why Trumbull could direct such a confrontational
film as Silent Running (Biskind 126). Most
clearly, however, the film provides an apocalyptic message that calls
contemporary humanity to action—save the forests now before they are
eliminated.
In Silent Running corporations seek to wipe out all remnants of
ecology for economic gain, so nostalgia comes from a more personal viewpoint,
that of Freeman Lowell. For example, the opening of Silent Running recalls a past where nature thrives, where plants
and animals are sympathetically depicted as “children” under the care of a
human “Holy Fool” or “St. Francis of Assisi.” Opening shots show close-ups of
snails, frogs, and fuzzy bunnies in a mossy forest, as well as a white-cloaked
man (Bruce Dern’s character, Freeman Lowell) caring for them and then
interacting with nature by swimming in a calm natural pool. Only after Freeman
climbs on shore do we realize that this ecosystem is constructed and protected
within a bio-dome. As shots of the dome draw further back, the dome’s location
becomes clear—this dome is floating in space and surrounded by stars. In the
world of Silent Running, technology
is necessary to save “nature.”
Nostalgia for the
nature enclosed in the dome is shattered by a loud reality in which Freeman’s
colleagues drive over his plants in four-wheelers. Company logos cover the
space station and even bins full of soil—Polaroid, AMF, Dow, American Airlines,
NA Rockwell, and Coca Cola support this “natural” setting. Yet a voice-over
claims these biosphere forests have been preserved as a way to re-foliate the
Earth. The narration explains, “On this first day of a new century, we dedicate
these last forests of a once beautiful nation in the hope that they will return
and grace our foul earth. Until that day may God bless these forests and the
great men that care for them.” As David Ingram puts it,
the film combines an “uneasy … nostalgia for a seemingly lost authentic
relationship between human beings and nonhuman nature, before the despoliations
of modernity, with a reliance on a technological fix to solve environmental
problems” (180).
In spite of these
corporate claims, only Freeman Lowell shows any nostalgia for a once-green
Earth. Lowell recalls with nostalgia a time when Earth was green and
ecologically diverse and laments the “dried synthetic crap” they now eat and
the unchanging Earth they left behind: “On earth everywhere you go it’s
seventy-five degrees. Everything’s the same. All the people are the same.” His
fellow crewmen, however, celebrate Earth’s sameness since there’s “no more
disease, no more poverty, [and] everyone has a job.” In fact, earlier in the
film when the other crewmen are playing poker, and Lowell talks about his
dreams for reestablishing the Earth’s parks and forests, one of the crewmen
argues, “It’s been too long. People have other things to do now.” Lowell waxes
nostalgically on a time when the Earth was green. The other crewmen—and
everyone else, it seems—see nature as expendable. For them, a better Earth is
as technologically controlled as their space station. Everyone looks happy in
the world of Silent Running—everyone but Lowell. When the crew hears about
the corporation’s plan to destroy their biospheres and put their ship back into
commercial business, all but Lowell are overjoyed, since it means they’ll go home
to Earth. Lowell sees only the losses they’ll all suffer: “no more beauty,”
“imagination,” “frontiers.” Children will “never … be able to see the simple
wonder of a leaf in their hands,” Lowell asserts.
Lowell sees nature as so
necessary and irreplaceable that he willingly kills his colleagues to protect
the last dome and save the last eco-memory of a natural Earth ecosystem. For
Lowell, nature is necessary, but so are human companions, so he cannot bear the
guilt his crime causes him through memories. Like a bottle thrown into an
ocean, Lowell thrusts the last biosphere into space. Our last view of the dome
shows us Dewey in charge of its (artificially) well-lit forest. But death is
the only solution for Lowell, as a tragic hero who can’t bear the memories he holds.
Eco-memory and memories of human friendships merge in Silent Running, suggesting that Lowell’s ultimate solution is
only partially effective.
Friday, July 8, 2016
Seeking Sustainable Development in McCabe and Mrs. Miller
Most western films with mining at
their center examine dichotomies between corporate and small time miners or
between miners and ranchers or farmers in traditional ways, with the individual
miner usually defeating the corporate miner or rancher. The conflicts in these
westerns continue the big guy versus little guy theme found in other western
films; yet the mining on display, no matter how buried in the action-packed
plotline, reveals environmental issues worth exploring—those associated with
both mining and the long-term consequences of mining techniques themselves.
These issues and their consequences are especially evident in McCabe and Mrs. Miller (1971). We
assert, then, that McCabe and Mrs. Miller
not only reveals that environmental history but also proposes a more effective
way to maintain the ecology of the mining West: sustainable development. In the
mining westerns we viewed, the conflict between corporate and individual miners
also reveals two conflicting views of ecology: fair use methods of corporations
and sustainable development aspirations of individuals wishing to maintain
resources for future generations of a growing community. McCabe and Mrs. Miller highlights a more effective way to maintain
the ecology of the mining West: sustainable development.
McCabe and Mrs. Miller
focuses on zinc mining and comments on environmental consequences of mining
techniques, responding to an environmental history that highlights the dangers
of unrestrained land ownership. The film both perpetuates and blurs the
dichotomy between two “classes” of miners, while examining ecological issues in
both obvious and opaque ways. The debate between miners and their methods of
destroying or sustaining the land continues in western films, whether in
relation to a sampling of classic Anthony Mann westerns, cult westerns from
Budd Boetticher, or revisionist westerns from Sam Peckinpah, Robert Altman, and
Nils Gaup. We contend, however, that mining westerns like these grounded the
conflicts they illustrate in an environmental history that has not as yet been
resolved. McCabe and Mrs. Miller reveals
that environmental history and proposes a more effective way to sustain the
ecology of the mining West. McCabe and
Mrs Miller also responds to a mining history and culture that was a product
of the General Mining Act of 1872. The
General Mining Act of 1872 is a United States federal law that authorizes and
governs prospecting and mining for economic minerals, such as gold, platinum,
and silver, on federal public lands.
McCabe and Mrs. Miller
rests on a naturalist philosophy and takes a connection between dying men and a
dying landscape even further than Ride
the High Country, since the film’s hero, McCabe (Warren Beatty), literally
dies in the snow, his body buried in a blowing drift while the rest of the town
of Presbyterian Church attempts to put out a fire burning down their house of
worship. The film also grapples with the same “big guys” versus “little guys”
conflict found in other mining films, catalyzing with an altercation between
McCabe and a mining corporation from Bear Claw, the town down the mountain from
Presbyterian Church, but in McCabe and
Mrs. Miller, the community nearly fails and is either bought or destroyed
by a corporate mining company. The mining company wants to buy McCabe’s
holdings and take over the town, but McCabe holds out for too much money and is
killed after a long shootout with the corporation’s assassins. In McCabe and Mrs. Miller, eco-resistance
destroys corporate gunslingers. But McCabe
and Mrs. Miller illustrates the cost of that vigilante justice: the death
of a hero and the community he attempts to build.
McCabe and Mrs. Miller
deconstructs the Western genre, blowing up the hero myth McCabe at first seemed
to represent. The film does not valorize violence or a Western hero. Instead,
McCabe hides in an open shed and shoots his pursuers stealthily and out of
fear. The community works together to put out the church fire. McCabe fights
alone. He eradicates the three faces of the corporation, so the community can
rebuild itself on the values of a church rather than the brothel both McCabe
and Mrs. Miller have left behind. But neither McCabe’s death nor Mrs. Miller’s
departure are valorized. Instead, extreme close-ups show McCabe’s snow-covered
body and ice-streaked face and Mrs. Miller’s oblivious opiate stare, two views
that illustrate their powerless state. McCabe and Mrs. Miller confront nature
and build a business community, confront a mining corporation and seem to
succeed, even in the face of their own sacrifices. But they die in the face of
change and represent a dying frontier and the drive toward a more traditional
community like that in Pale Rider. In
McCabe and Mrs. Miller the community
members won’t quit. Instead, they will build homes, schools, churches, raise
their families, and sink roots—just as they did in Pale Rider. And those roots rest on zinc mining without the corporate
interference that kills off towns and community ideals.
Monday, June 20, 2016
Intentionally Small Urban Living?
As a documentary version of a blog, Urban Living, Intentionally Small: Urban Living in North Carolina illustrates how an architect in Raleigh, NC, creates a sustainable lifestyle by choosing to downsize. To encourage both efficiency and green living, filmmaker and architect Nicole Alverez decides to rent a 300 square foot apartment above a dentist office rather than adopting the large house culture of most cities and suburbs around the U.S.
The documentary introduces Alvarez and her home, but it also provides a strong rationale for downsizing that takes the joys of everyday life into account. Alvarez's initial studio apartment was small but well-designed for her single lifestyle. Everything she needed was in reach in and outside the apartment. She could reach the sink and recycling bin from her kitchen table, for example. And she could walk to her architecture design firm.
As Alvarez explains in her blog,
"It was the first time that I could walk to a coffee shop, a few bars, a yoga studio, even my job. I felt connected to my community in a way I never had before. I quickly realized that what I loved most about living in a small space was the way of living that inevitably followed. Less space meant less physical and mental clutter, and therefore more time to enjoy life."
After viewing the documentary and reading Alvarez's blog, I'm not quite ready to move out of my 1100 square foot house, but I am ready to give away and recycle some of my unnecessary belongings. As Alvarez suggests, "Living comfortably in a small space is all about editing out what you don’t need – both in your physical environment and your general lifestyle." Even in the 1170 square foot city house she now shares with her husband and dog, Alvarez embraces this advice. I'm willing to begin this editing process today.
Thursday, June 16, 2016
Gudmundsson's Mountain Mourning and Stewardship
BJ Gudmundsson’s Mountain
Mourning (2007) stands out because it explicitly states its Christian
position but also because it too agues for sustainable development without
attempting an evenhanded approach to MTR. The film was presented by Christians
for the Mountains and bases its opposition to Mountaintop Removal Mining on
biblical assertions like “The Earth is the Lord’s.” As in other MTR
documentaries, Mountain Mourning highlights the richness of mountain
resources and the cultures they have sustained for centuries, but here facts
are delivered with sacred music in the background. “Blessed Jesus” accompanies
information about the hardwood forests in Appalachia, along with pristine
scenes of deer, ginseng, and black cohosh. A billboard declaring, “This is Coal
Country” breaks the meditative tone of the film, and the narration reinforces
the conflict. The billions of tons of coal used to produce over fifty percent
of our electricity results in sulfur dioxide pollutants that are the main cause
of acid rain. To more easily reach this coal commodity, according to the film,
MTR replaced much of underground mining, the narrator reveals, explaining the
destruction left behind when 600 feet of a mountaintop is removed to reach the
exposed coal seams, so that dragline cranes can scoop out all the mineral like
seeds out of a split melon.
Costs to the landscape range from loss of forests through
clear-cutting, erosion, runoff, and black water spills, streams buried by
valley fills, construction of slurry sludge ponds to store black water left
from coal processing and slurry spills resulting from weakened dams. The film
shows floods caused by slurry spills and erosion to illustrate dangerous
repercussions of MTR. According to Gudmundsson, half of the mountains in
Southern West Virginia will be gone in the next 20 years if permits are
submitted and approved at the current rate.
Other costs are economic but negatively affect human and
nonhuman nature, as well. Generated in part by MTR erosion, devastating floods
destroyed 5000 homes and businesses in 2001, and 4000 in 2002. MTR’s
repercussions are pushing people out of the hollers and into FEMA trailers.
Whole communities must be relocated away from MTR sites because of blasting,
contaminated drinking water, and dust. An enormous number of jobs have been
lost in the state in the last three decades, decreasing the number of miners
from 120,000 to fewer than 15,000. Counties in West Virginia are now like Third
World countries, the film declares, noting that McDowell County, West Virginia
is now the eighth poorest in the United States. Over 3000 children live there
in poverty, asserts the narrator.
In spite of these dire conditions, however, the film begins
and ends with hope as it supports sustainable development and maintains its
anti-MTR stance. Musicians support a “Vigil for the Mountains” that opens and
closes the film, an attempt to raise awareness of mountaintop removal mining
and its consequences. Instead of experts offering underground mining as a
viable solution to MTR, this film shows us a banner behind musicians at the
vigil arguing for alternative energy sources. The film also ends with its
beginning Biblical message: “The Earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness
thereof,” a vision that points to the power of a rhetoric of hope, this time
based in a more powerful argument for sustainable development that maintains
its opposition to corporate coalmining and its exploitation of the natural
world.
Rise Up! West Virginia (2007) and Alternative Solutions to Mountaintop Removal Mining
After watching Big Stone Gap (2014), a less than memorable romantic comedy about a pharmacy owner who falls in love with a Virginia coal miner in Appalachia, I yearned for more authentic representations of my mountain home. B.J. Gudmundsson’s Rise Up! West Virginia (2007) offers a glimpse.
Rise Up! West Virginia presents new, radical
arguments against Mountaintop Removal Mining. The film demands alternative
energy sources to meet sustainable development goals and effectively maintains
its rhetoric against MTR. Even though the film and its subjects strive for and
build their arguments on the need for wider distribution of fair use
commodities, they also argue against coalmining in general and maintain their
position against MTR and corporate coalmining throughout the films. The fact
that a large percentage of America’s power is coal generated does not sway them from
their demand for new forms of less destructive
energy production and consumption.
Rise Up! West Virginia presents George Daughtery, a
West Virginia attorney, arguing, “coal mining hasn’t saved the state yet” by
effectively juxtaposing images of the pristine mountains that may become a
memory with the hell MTR leaves in its wake. Judy Bonds’ narration accompanies
pristine images of West Virginia mountains that provide, as Bonds explains, the
“sense of place [that] pulls at you” and “makes Appalachians who they are.”
With authentic Appalachian music performed by West Virginia musicians, the film
highlights this need for a sense of place, even providing a “Bambi shot” of a
doe in a hardwood forest. The pure scene is contrasted with shots of mammoth
blasting destroying a mountain in Boone County, so, as the film states, the
mountain’s “guts are blown out” in a “manmade destruction.” The film also sets
up Appalachians as victims like the mountains, both of whom are exploited by
corporate mining companies with progressive views of resource exploitation. The
film argues that their state has been turned into a Third World colony and will
be abandoned after all the coal is brutally extracted.
After this opening that establishes the film’s conflict, a
focus on “sustainable energy and jobs” is reinforced with a musical celebration
of the land that remains at the Mountain Keepers Music Festival with Larry
Gibson, a landowner surrounded by MTR because he refused to sell his land or
mineral rights. The festival is meant to provide a voice for the anti-MTR
movement and to support alternative and sustainable energy sources that will
provide jobs for the region. These anti-MTR protesters align with the pristine
nature that could become a memory, like the fish in hollers, thousands of acres
of virgin forest, and sandstone rocks now lost because of MTR.
Although this film documents jobs lost because of the move
to MTR, arguments against coalmining chiefly rely on its environmental
consequences: timber lost to clear cutting, sludge dams breaking and destroying
towns and water sources, valley fills polluting wells and clogging up rivers
and streams, blasting not only decapitating mountains but covering whole towns
with toxic coal dust, even after covering a processing plant with a dome.
And the coalmining companies, especially Massey, are
established as the culprits for this destruction to the land and people of West
Virginia. A child in the film explains, “These coal mines are making us kids
sick,” while explaining Massey’s attempts to expand a coal preparation plant
near a school. The government, too, is held responsible for ongoing
destruction, since they overturn stays on permits and allow MTR and its
consequences to continue.
The film’s ending maintains both the bifurcation between the
big guys—corporate miners—and the little guys—citizens of West Virginia. But it
also continues its argument for sustainable development. Back at the music
festival protestors argue, “Turn off electric gadgets and demand renewable
energy.” And they offer suggestions for winning the war against MTR. According
to the film, Appalachians should elect responsible people to public office and
think of their neighbors. They should make phone calls and write letters. In a
nod back toward nostalgia, the film ends with another Bambi shot in a pristine forest
and an exclamation: “She’s worth more than all the power in the world,” so
“Rise Up! West Virginia,” the film asserts, providing a sense of hope that
moves beyond the seemingly hopeless context established in other anti-MTR
documentaries. With viable solutions to not only MTR but also coalmining and
our reliance on coal for our electricity, hope is preserved.
Wednesday, June 8, 2016
Reel Images: Gender, Genre and the Movies in English Studies--English Studies Summer Camp for High School Students
Reel Images: Gender, Genre, and
the Movies in English Studies at the English Studies Summer Camp
Eastern Illinois University will host the English Studies Summer Camp
July 24-30, 2016. We look forward to welcoming high school students who
share our love of reading and writing for years to come. This one-week
camp allows students to hone their English skills while providing them
with a chance to sample life on a college campus and meet peers with
similar interests. Offering courses that reflect students’ interests,
our engaged faculty and tranquil setting provide that perfect
opportunity for students to have an academically charged summer getaway
where they can grow as readers, writers, debaters, and English scholars!
This session will examine gender roles in genre films and
highlight ways at least some horror, screwball comedy, and animated movies
move beyond gender stereotypes. Students
will learn useful strategies for analyzing film and media portrayals of gender and apply them in a short creative or
analytic project in a medium of their choice.
A Message from Robin Murray, your
instructor for “Reel Images: Gender, Genre, and the Movies in English Studies”: Welcome! To prepare for this session,
all you need to do is watch your favorite movie (s) and/or television show(s)
and think about how you might classify it or them if you were searching for
them on Netflix. Do you like animated films or media? Do you like science
fiction or fantasy? Do you like dramas?
Once you have a classification, you’re
ready to begin analyzing! Once I have some idea of your favorite films and/or
TV shows, we’ll watch clips from them and apply strategies for analyzing them
in relation to film and media form, style, and gender representations.
To get
us started, we’ll watch clips from Cabin
in the Woods (2012), The Big Lebowski
(1998), and Frozen (2014), as
well as a variety of Netflix series, including Jessica Jones and The
Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt. One of our projects will be to develop a short
media project, like a blog, wiki, or podcast, so your film and media knowledge
and preferences will come in handy. Please bring them with you!
The EIU English Studies Summer Camp is a unique program that allows students to customize their program of study, selecting two sessions from a range of offerings in creative writing, literature, professional/academic writing, media studies, and more. Students grow academically and socially as they prepare for college and are mentored by expert faculty who share their passion for reading and writing. Students receive individual attention through small class sizes and gain skills in analyzing and crafting texts and expressing their ideas both verbally and through writing.
The camp offers two levels of discounted tuition:
- a residency rate which includes tuition, housing, recreation, and three meals per day, and
- a commuter rate which includes tuition, some recreational activities, and daily lunches.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




































